Collection: Shaving Soap - Tallow & Vegan, Made in USA

Small-batch artisan shaving soap, made in the USA since 2014. Our tallow soaps are built on whole donkey milk for a slick, protective lather that stays workable through several passes. Prefer to skip animal ingredients? The vegan base swaps in shea, kokum, mango and cocoa butters for comparable cushion. Either way you get a dense, traditional lather, not canned foam.

Which base is right for you?

All of our tallow soaps start from whole donkey milk. The bases differ in what goes on top of it.

  • Siero (tallow-based): tallow, donkey milk, water buffalo milk and whey. The densest, most cushioning lather we make, and the base under most of our scented soaps.
  • Tallow (plain): classic tallow and donkey milk, clean and simple. Also offered as a vegan variant at the same price.
  • Vegan (butter-based): shea, kokum, mango and cocoa butters in place of tallow. Comparable cushion, and the right pick if you avoid animal-derived ingredients.

Where to start

  • Sensitive skin, or you want unscented: Bare Siero.
  • One soap to do everything: Eroe, our best all-rounder.
  • Classic barbershop scent: 1776, a traditional fougère.
  • Bold and oriental: King of Oud.
  • Tobacco lovers: Dulci Tobacco.
  • Your first artisan soap: Bare Naked on the plain Tallow base.

Still deciding? Read our ranked guide to the best tallow shaving soap, or what tallow actually does in a shaving soap.

Made in small batches in the USA. Whole donkey milk in the tallow bases, a butter blend in the vegan base.

Filter
Showing 72 of 72 products
Sort by:

Filter (0)

72 products
Clear
Noce di Cocco Shaving Soap, Tallow + Vegan

Noce di Cocco Shaving Soap, Tallow + Vegan

Regular price
From $21.99
Sale price
From $21.99
Regular price
Masquerade Shaving Soap

Masquerade Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $21.99
Sale price
From $21.99
Regular price
Timmermann Classic 1869 Shaving Soap

Timmermann Classic 1869 Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $21.99
Sale price
From $21.99
Regular price
Dulci Tobacco Shaving Soap

Dulci Tobacco Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price
Aranceto Shaving Soap

Aranceto Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $24.99
Sale price
From $24.99
Regular price
Transition Shaving Soap

Transition Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price
PasteurVision Shaving Soap: Rum & Tobacco

PasteurVision Shaving Soap: Rum & Tobacco

Regular price
$24.99
Sale price
$24.99
Regular price
Monaco Royale Shaving Soap, Tallow + Vegan

Monaco Royale Shaving Soap, Tallow + Vegan

Regular price
From $21.99
Sale price
From $21.99
Regular price
Renegade Shaving Soap

Renegade Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $23.99
Sale price
From $23.99
Regular price
Inizio Shaving Soap

Inizio Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price
Enchant Shaving Soap

Enchant Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $23.99
Sale price
From $23.99
Regular price
Ikigai Shaving Soap

Ikigai Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $23.99
Sale price
From $23.99
Regular price
Club Yanka Shaving Soap

Club Yanka Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $21.99
Sale price
From $21.99
Regular price
$29.99
Florida Man Shaving Soap

Florida Man Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price
DFS 2021 / Tobaccowala Shaving Soap

DFS 2021 / Tobaccowala Shaving Soap

Regular price
$26.99
Sale price
$26.99
Regular price
Jupiter Shaving Soap

Jupiter Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price
Nightcap Tallow Shaving Soap

Nightcap Tallow Shaving Soap

Regular price
$26.99
Sale price
$26.99
Regular price
Mogud Shaving Soap

Mogud Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price
Timmermann Green Label 1869 Shaving Soap

Timmermann Green Label 1869 Shaving Soap

Regular price
$29.99
Sale price
$29.99
Regular price
La Supérieure DFS 2021 Shaving Cream

La Supérieure DFS 2021 Shaving Cream

Regular price
$21.99
Sale price
$21.99
Regular price
Peach Karma Shaving Soap

Peach Karma Shaving Soap

Regular price
From $22.99
Sale price
From $22.99
Regular price

Frequently asked questions

What is shaving soap, and how is it different from shaving cream?
Shaving soap is a puck you load with a wet brush to build lather in a bowl or on your face. It gives more control and cushion than canned foam, and one puck lasts far longer. Creams are softer and faster to load, while soaps give a denser lather. WhollyKaw makes both.
Is tallow good in a shaving soap?
Tallow is prized in traditional wet shaving for glide and cushion. Its fatty-acid profile is close to the oils skin makes on its own, which is why many shavers describe a tallow lather as slick going on and comfortable afterward. If you avoid animal ingredients, our vegan butter base is built to match that cushion.
Should I choose a tallow or a vegan base?
Choose tallow (Siero or plain Tallow) for the most cushioning lather in the traditional style. Choose vegan if you avoid animal ingredients; it uses shea, kokum, mango and cocoa butters for comparable slickness.
What is the best shaving soap for sensitive skin?
Start unscented. Fragrance is the most common irritant in any soap, so our Bare line (Bare Siero and Bare Naked) leaves it out while keeping the full lather. Load a little extra water for a wetter, slicker cushion.
How long does one puck last?
Used with a brush, a single puck typically lasts several months of daily shaving. You only need a small amount to load the brush, so a little goes a long way.